Top 10 Insurance Complaints

There are plenty of formal complaints filed each year against insurers from their clients who believe they got a raw deal after paying insurance premiums month after month, making them wonder what are the benefits of insurance and why does it exist if there are so many issues with insurance companies.

This post reveals the top reasons people file formal complaints and the top five complaints by type of coverage. If you are unhappy with your current insurance company, enter your ZIP code in our free quote comparison tool to find the best, affordable companies in your area.

Top Insurance Complaints

The data is from a few years back, but it’s important to note that the numbers take a while to “come in,” and the rankings do not change much from year to year.

According to data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), a total of 195,669 consumer complaints were confirmed in the 2008 calendar year. Keep in mind that the NAIC does not collect all insurance complaint data from all states.

Insurance is not nationally regulated, rather regulated by each state insurance laws, so there are no official national numbers out there for us to provide you.

Top Five Reasons for Insurance Complaints

The numbers above reveal the most common reasons why a complaint is filed regardless of the type of insurance we’re dealing with.

While these numbers paint a pretty clear picture of the distaste consumers have for their insurance companies, we should also consider the rank of which lines of insurance cause the most headaches, so here goes…

Top Five Complaints by Type of Coverage

What to consider about these numbers?

Most importantly, you will probably notice that the number of consumer complaints coincide with the overall number of insured in the U.S. There are more health insurance policies than car insurance policies and so on down the line.

Also, it’s important to note that the average American does not read and fully understand their insurance coverage and probably expects money to come quickly (and without dispute) after a loss.

Much of the disappointment related to item number one on the list is related to the U.S. justice system, which moves slowly.

Often, insurance claims that aren’t cut-and-dry wind up in arbitration or court, and no settlements are paid until the fat lady sings. This rarely occurs at the speed someone expects when they have suffered an insured loss.

Many claim denial complaints (number 2 on the list) would be pretty clear-cut if everyone read and understood their policies. Many people mistakenly believe that their premium dollars are exchanged for a guarantee that they will never have an uninsured loss.

Item number 3 on the list is also a hot complaint topic due to a general public misconception of how insurance works.

The concept of insurance is to get us back to EXACTLY where we were prior to our loss. Much of the public believes that an insurance claim is similar to a winning lottery ticket and expects a windfall for their loss. This is simply not the case.

Remember, insurers bank on the fact that you most likely won’t be switching insurance companies. Retention rates are high in the insurance world, and even though every commercial out there talks about switching, most people leave their policies untouched.

Filing an Insurance Complaint

If you want to complain about your insurance, you can contact your licensed insurance agent, call an executive in the company, ask a third party to medicate your claim dispute or file a complaint using State Department of Insurance contact info, as they control insurance activity and insurer compliance with state laws and regulations. Moreover, you can ask for arbitration if that’s an option in your policy, or file a legal claim against your company in court.

Read more: How to Negotiate With Insurance Companies

If you purchased your policy through an agent, you can use this person as an advocate to help you with your complaint form. The state insurance department is also the official complaint complaint-taker for insurance problems. They will investigate your matter and determine if any insurance law has been broken.

The number of complaints in the state department of insurance is a matter of public record, because it reveals how many consumers have bought a policy, how much those policies are written for, and the number of complaints. The department of insurance then divides the number of complaints by the policies written and calculates the complaint ratio. If the complaint ratio is high, this indicates that the insurance company is bad.

If you don’t like who you’re with, shop around – there are plenty of companies out there willing to take your premium dollar, and there’s a decent chance they’ll do so for cheaper than your existing carrier!